In Germany, trail operators will soon no longer be liable for falling branches | Ride MTB

In Germany, trail operators will soon no longer be liable for falling branches

Mountainbiker Naturgefahr waldtypische Gefahr Deutschland

Photo: Shutterstock

Good news for community trail managers and other operators of bike trails in Germany: As of recently, they are no longer liable if mountain bikers fall victim to a hazard typical of the forest—for example, if they crash because of a fallen branch. At the urging of the DIMB, the Bundestag has clarified the Forest Act.

“Duty to ensure public safety”—the term is not only cumbersome but also a killer argument against bike trails in the forest. It means that the operators of such trails are responsible for ensuring that it is possible to ride on them as safely as possible. For years, this has applied not only to the trail itself but also to its surroundings, especially trees that could fall onto the trail, either entirely or in parts. 

As a result of this duty to ensure safety, those responsible for a trail had to conduct regular tree inspections and document their observations. For a volunteer-based organization, this was virtually impossible to manage in the long run. 

The fear of liability lawsuits apparently went so far that forest owners even removed benches because they feared being held responsible if a branch fell on the head of someone sitting on one. 

That will soon come to an end. The German Mountain Bike Interest Group (DIMB) has long advocated to lawmakers that trail operators should not be held liable for damages resulting from hazards typical of forests. However, since this was not explicitly stated in the law, the amendment to the Forest Act helps groups that are planning or already operating a trail. Just as hikers use forest trails at their own risk, mountain bikers should do the same on trails. Those responsible must continue to maintain the trail itself—with all its elements—in such a way that it does not pose a hazard, such as through holes that aren’t visible when approaching, rotten Northshore elements, or tools lying along the trail.

What the New Article Means for Existing Trails

The German Bundestag has now passed the clarification regarding liability for natural hazards. For it to take effect, the Bundesrat must still give its approval. The Bundesrat already expressed support for the amendment in August, so it is expected that the confirmation will be a mere formality. However, this legislative revision is not on the agenda for the Bundesrat’s next meeting on November 20 (there are 70 other items on the agenda). After that, the Bundesrat will not meet again until December 20; the agenda for that meeting has not yet been made public. It appears that the new rules will not take effect until 2027.

Groups currently in negotiations with landowners can already refer to the regulations that will soon take effect. These will most likely remain in effect until the trail is built. The DIMB recommends that organizations already operating a public trail amend their contracts to reflect the new legal situation.

The amended Section 14 of the Federal Forest Act can be found on page 15 of these Bundestag minutes. 

The Bike Nature Movement, of which the DIMB is a member, has published a guide for trail organizations on the duty to ensure public safety.


You'll find this content in the Ride newsletter

Get news like this delivered to your inbox with Ride’s weekly newsletter. Early Monday morning, Ride sends out a clear summary of all the news from the past week. It also includes all newly added tours and active job postings. Sign up now for the weekly newsletter through your user account at
ride-mtb.com/newsletter

Note: This content has been automatically translated from German. Please report any incorrect translations.